A one-eyed cat named Will is trying to impress his girlfriend Wendy, so he tells her how he lost his eye in a fight with Wally, a comically large fox. However, he exaggerates some details, such as his own physical abilities and who the true victor of the fight was. Unfortunately, Will’s tall tale is suddenly blown wide open when Wally (who is notably not as obese as Will described him) returns for a rematch.